Based on Mitch Cullin's 2005 novel A Slight Trick of the Mind, Mr. Holmes is not your typical crime-mystery. The film, which was directed by Bill Condon and adapted to the screen by Jeffrey Hatcher, is more of a psychological exploration of a decaying mind. Through revelations of regrets and insights, the protagonist, an aging Sherlock Holmes, can finally find his redemption.
Mr. Holmes builds up slowly; maybe a little too slow for the pace of our day and age. Yet it is masterfully constructed, confidently directed and powerfully performed. Ian McKellen fully inhabits Holmes with a skill second to none. Laura Linney and young Milo Parker shine in supporting roles.
I found the film to be quite dark. Expecting a typical Holmes murder mystery, I was not prepared for an altogether different journey; one that involves aging, dementia and reflections of a master upon his past mistakes. Yet, I also found Mr. Holmes to be the perfect antidote to the recent wave of Sherlock Holmes films; ones that made his character into a martial art master, engulfed by special effects. Not that there is anything wrong with those action flicks that are, quite frankly, entertaining, yet lack the sense of true wisdom the Holmes character used to inspired. Mr. Holmes, the film, reveals a finer aspect of the famous character; one that enables the seasoned detective to find fault with his own unquestionable sense of logic. Saying more will be a plot spoiler so let’s leave it at that.
Mr. Holmes requires patience and some preparation. If you are ready for a different perspective on the old master, you may enjoy this ride.